“Now the dwelling of God is with men, and he will live with them. They will be his people, and God himself will be with them and be their God. 4 He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away.” (Rev 21.3-4)
Sunday, March 31, 2013
The Good News about Easter - We're NOT going to Heaven
Friday, May 20, 2011
Why the rapture won’t happen . . . EVER!
His appearance in the clouds will be veiled to the human eye and NO ONE WILL SEE HIM. He will slip in, slip out; move in to get His jewels and slip out as under the cover of night.[1]
The word ‘rapture’ means to snatch away or take away. [. . .] Someday, [. . .] Jesus Christ is coming to take away all those who believe in Him. He is coming to meet all true believers in the air.[2]
36 “No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. 37 As it was in the days of Noah, so it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. 38 For in the days before the flood, people were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, up to the day Noah entered the ark; 39 and they knew nothing about what would happen until the flood came and took them all away. That is how it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. 40 Two men will be in the field; one will be taken and the other left. 41 Two women will be grinding with a hand mill; one will be taken and the other left.”
13 Brothers, we do not want you to be ignorant about those who fall asleep, or to grieve like the rest of men, who have no hope. 14 We believe that Jesus died and rose again and so we believe that God will bring with Jesus those who have fallen asleep in him. 15 According to the Lord’s own word, we tell you that we who are still alive, who are left till the coming [παρουσία] of the Lord, will certainly not precede those who have fallen asleep. 16 For the Lord himself will come down from heaven, with a loud command, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet call of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. 17 After that, we who are still alive and are left will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet [ἀπάντησιν] the Lord in the air. And so we will be with the Lord forever. 18 Therefore encourage each other with these words.
Friday, November 5, 2010
Worship as a Cosmic Victory
Are we standing on the edge of the end?
In Christian speak, are we living in the last days?
Ignatius thought so. After encouraging the Ephesian Christians to follow Jesus' example of rejection and pray for those who oppose them, he writes, "These are the end times" ἒσχατοι καιροί (Ign. Eph. 11.1). The proper response these end times is either fear of wrath or love of the grace that has already come. This grace is from Jesus for "only in Christ Jesus is to be found true life." For Ignatius, as with the rest of the NT, the "end times" are inaugurated in the Christ-event. Ignatius frames up the present situation as either imminent judgment or present grace anticipating vindication.
Ignatius encourages the Ephesians as a well-established church "secure" (12.1) affiliated with Paul whose martyrdom proved him worthy (12.2). As a church firmly established in Apostolic tradition, Ignatius encourages them to gather as much as possible, "For when you frequently gather as a congregation, the powers of Satan are destroyed, and his destructive force is vanquished by the harmony of your faith" (13.1). Ignatius invests cosmic significance in the unity of the church. It is not unlike Paul's letter to the Ephesians where he describes the church as the "manifold wisdom of God" giving notice to the "rulers and authorities in heavenly places" (Eph 3.10). The victory was won by Christ, for in the incarnation, "All magic was vanquished and every bondage of evil came to naught. Ignorance was destroyed and the ancient reign was brought to ruin, when God became manifest in a human way, for the newness of eternal life" (19.3). The cosmic victory of the incarnation is embodied in the faithful church. Incredibly, Ignatius teaches that the church participates in Christ's cosmic victory over Satan as it gathers in worship!
Ignatius also warns that disobedience leads to death. His chief concern is to guard against false teaching. From what we gather from the NT, the Ephesians were vigilantly opposed to false teaching (Rev 2.2, 6; cf. Acts 20.29-31). Not only will those who corrupt their homes not inherit the kingdom of God (Ign. Eph 16.1; cf. 1 Cor 3.16), but even more significant those who corrupt the faith "for which Jesus was crucified" will face fiery judgment (Ign. Eph. 16.2). Ignatius is deeply concerned to keep the teaching of the church pure and so warns strongly against any sort of false teaching.
How different was Ignatius' eschatology from many contemporary Christians?
What would he have thought of "the rapture"? What would he say to someone that told him he would be ripped out of the world to avoid suffering before Jesus' return?
I imagine he would tell them they were corrupting the faith for which Jesus died.
Wednesday, October 6, 2010
Unity based on the Creator Judge (1 Clement 21-27)
Clement's exhortation to unity to the Corinthians is argued from God's character and eschatology as portrayed in the OT.
Clement thoroughly addresses the division taking place at Corinth and points to numerous OT examples, Jesus and the apostles to correct the problem. Next, Clement moves to arguing from the character of God. Drawing from a rich OT creation theology, Clement portrays God as the gracious creator of the peaceful earth. So he writes, "The great Creator and Master of all appointed all these things to be in peace and harmony, bringing great benefits to all things, but most especially to us, who flee to his compassion through our Lord Jesus Christ" (1 Clem 20.11). Implicit in this creation theology is a critique of the dissention that had engulfed the Corinthian church.
Not only is God's glory on display in creation, but God is an all-powerful judge (1 Clement 21.1‒9). Clement uses a form of Proverbs 20.27. The LXX reads, "The light of the Lord is the breath of man, which searches the inner belly" whereas Clement writes, "the Spirit of the Lord is a lamp searching the deepest parts of the stomach." Obviously, the "deep parts of the stomach" or "belly" is a euphemism for "inner self" or hidden things‒a euphemism that Clement feels no need to translate. While Clement's passage makes less sense, it communicates the same point. In the LXX (and MT) the breath of man is from God and searches the inner parts of a man. In Clement the spirit/breath (pnema) of God searches the depths of each person. His point in citing this text is to remind the Corinthians that their division is not hidden from God. "For he is the one who explores our understandings and desires. His breath is in us, and when he wishes, he will remove it" (21.9).
According to Clement, however, God's role as judge does not overshadow his grace. "Faith in Christ" (ἡ ἐν Χριστῳ πίστις) is the guarantee of grace. Christ speaks Psalm 34.11-17, 19 and Ps 32.10 through the Holy Spirit. Here obviously, deliverance is offered to those who repent. The gifts of this repentance are ready to be dispensed as quickly as his judgment. Clement even betrays an imminent eschatology citing Isa 13.22LXX, "Quickly he will come and not delay" (23.5). The LXX reads "[referring to the day of the Lord in Isa 13.19] it is coming quickly and it will not delay." The context of Isaiah 13 is a judgment oracle against prideful Babylon. Clement uses this as a judgment oracle against the prideful who would divide the Corinthian church. The imminent eschatology spills over into 1 Clement 24 as well. Clement reminds the Corinthians of "the future resurrection that is about to occur" (τὴν μέλλοθσαν ἀνάστασιν ἒσεσθαι 24.1). Clement illustrates the resurrection with Greek imagery of the rising sun, cycle of crops (24.2‒5) and the Phoenix bird (25.1‒5) along with classic rabbinic "how much more" logic arguing that these things images pale in comparison to the promise of the resurrection (26.1‒3).
Clement exhorts, "Let our souls, therefore, be bound by this hope in to the one who is faithful in his promises and upright in his judgments" (27.1). Clement prays that "his [God's] faithfulness would be rekindled in us" (27.3). Here is a beautiful image of salvation- God's faithfulness at work in us!
Monday, May 3, 2010
apocalyptic made easy? – a review of craig hill’s In God’s Time

Any popular-level book on eschatology endorsed by the likes of Eugene Peterson, Luke Timothy Johnson, Jürgen Moltmann and John J. Collins merits some attention. Hill intended to write "a book for people who want to come to grips with what the Bible says about the future" (vii). The people he's addressing, he hopes, are the non-experts, laymen and pastors. His writing is lucid, compelling and sometimes downright poetic.
He begins the book with a brief chapter on the eschatological nature of the Christian faith. In the vein of Barth, Moltmann and Schweitzer Hill argues, "Christianity is irreducibly eschatological" (4). Accurately, and tellingly, he roots the eschatological outlook of Christianity in the resurrection of Jesus. Unfortunately, the eschatological perspective of the NT, he suggests, has been demythologized by the modern world. This isn't just a problem with moderns, but is noticeable in the pre-modern cosmology of the early Christians and rooted in a view of creation that Hill considers untenable. Still, Hill thinks eschatology is salvageable, as the core of Christian theology, but not without dealing with difficult questions.
He begins with a book that looks to be about eschatology, but the content is quite different. What he presents in the rest of the book is a history of religions approach to Christianity. So, his second chapter, "First things First: The Bible," is about the nature and authority of the Bible. Though starting out as a "fundamentalist teenager" Hill has moved on to a more nuanced faith. He writes, "More than twenty-five years and three theological degrees later, I am still a Christian. The core of my faith has not changed all that substantially, but my understanding of the Bible has" (14). I think he is correct in his movement beyond the language of "inerrancy" for understanding the nature of Biblical authority. Still, I was frustrated by his approach that leveled out the distinctiveness of the Bible in favor of finding out what is common to the Bible and other religions.
In his third chapter, Hill gives a brief but helpful account of biblical history. He focuses on prophesy and biblical revelation within the context of the Ancient world. He is correct in suggesting that "biblical prophecy as a whole is more concerned with influencing the present than with revealing the future" (33). His views are decidedly less conservative wholeheartedly embracing source criticism. Still, his presentation of the meaning and function of prophesy is helpful and a welcome alternative to the divination approach to eschatology found in the LaHaye's and Hagee's.
Chapter four, cheekily titled "Apocalypse Then," is an extended introduction to Jewish apocalyptic literature. Here is obviously dependent on John J. Collins and R.H. Charles, but still manages to present a helpful introduction to the apocalyptic material that is inaccessible to the average Bible reader.
After analyzing non-canonical Jewish apocalyptic, Hill looks specifically at the books of Daniel and Revelation. He insists that there is in fact very little difference between these apocalypses and the works of early Judaism that were not canonized. He mostly takes the party-line of contemporary scholarship (a late date for Daniel, and standard fare on Revelation). He does, however, occasionally take odd positions on some issues. I was dumbfounded by his odd suggestion that chapters 19 and 20 of Revelation are "two popular but competing scenarios, the first of an earthly and limited messianic reign and the second of a cosmic and eternal kingdom" (126). Though Hill is comfortable with that kind of bizarre discrepancy, I sincerely doubt John was and it seems like a genuine lack of effort in trying to explain what is happening in these important chapters. Overall, I think Hill's work on Revelation suffers significantly from failing to take account of the structure of Revelation.
Having spent time in apocalyptic, Hill moves to Jesus and eschatology. He argues for an eschatological Jesus in the same tradition as E.P. Sanders, N.T. Wright and Dale Allison Jr. This chapter is a very helpful and readable introduction to the evidence, which I find overwhelming, that Jesus was an eschatological prophet. Oddly, Hill spends very little time on the most significant eschatological discourse of Jesus (Mt 24.1‒51 || Mark 13.1‒37 || Luke 21.5‒36). It receives only about two and a half pages and Hill explains nothing but his lack of attention with the statement, "many of the apocalyptic elements of this chapter are unparalleled elsewhere in the Gospels. It is possible that Jesus said these things, but it seems just as likely (if not more so) that these verses reflect primarily the hopes, experiences, and concerns of believers a generation removed from Jesus" (165). Why he excludes the most apocalyptic material attributed to Jesus is nothing short of puzzling.
The last major chapter of Hill's book "The Once and Future Kingdom" is a discussion of eschatology mostly focused on the Pauline corpus. The whole discussion is framed in terms of the old "future" vs "realized" eschatology. He places the NT writings somewhere on the spectrum of "future" and "realized" and allows the two poles to serve as theological yardsticks. The description of theology as falling somewhere along that eschatological spectrum is a load to heavy to be borne by the simplistic categories (e.g. 190). Still, his account was a vivid and fresh reading the eschatological outlook of the NT as a whole.
I find it unlikely that In God's Time would be well received in evangelical circles, which despite the way Hill writes, are not the same as fundamentalists though they do sometimes overlap. While his writing is sometimes poetic, his argument is overly-simplified and sometimes oddly suspicious of the canonical texts. This is a helpful book for someone trying to communicate the meaning of apocalyptic eschatology to those without any frame of reference, but it should not be the only, or even primary introduction.
